দেওয়ানী : দেওয়ানী আপীল
Bangladesh Form no. 3702
East Bengal Form No.3702
District : Naogaon
nvB‡KvU© wefvM dig bs (‡R) 3
HIGH COURT FORM No. (j) 3.
Avwc‡ji iv‡qi wk‡ivbvgv
HEADING OF JUDGMENT ON APPEAL.
‡Rjv- hyM¥ †Rjv RR (cÖ_g Av`vjZ), bIMuv Gi Kvh©vjq|
In the Court of Joint District Judge
Joint District Judge 1st Court, Naogaon.
Present: Md. Tazul Islam Miah
Joint District Judge.
Joint District Judge 1st Court, Naogaon.
Date of Delivery of Judgment: ‡ivR iweevi, 27 kÖveY 1431 e½vã.
Sunday 11 August, 2024.
Other Class Appeal No. 90 of 2011.
Form the decree of Learned Assistant Judge Court, Atrai, Naogaon.
And made in Suit No. Other Class Suit no. 452 of 1984.
1. ‡gvt Avãyj gwR` mi`vi w`s
Avwc‡j›U-/ev`x Appellant (s)
Versus
1. wKqvgZ Djøvni Gi g„Zy¨‡Z Zvi ˆea Iqvwik †gvQvt dzjRvb †eIqv w`s
‡imcb‡W›U-/weev`x (Respondent(s)
This appeal coming on this day (or having been heard on) 11/08/ 2022… in the presence of:
Rbve †gvt Rvgvj DwÏb gvnvjZ, weÁ GW&‡fv‡KU; AvcxjKvix/ev`x c‡¶|
Rbve ‡gvt †gvRvnviæj nK mi`vi, weÁ GW&‡fv‡KU; ‡imcb‡W›U/ weev`x c‡¶|
and having stood for consideration to this day, the Court delivered the following judgment :-
Bnv GKwU ¯^Z¡ †Nvlbvi †gvKÏgvi ‡`vZidv Lvwi‡Ri ivq I wWwµ evwZ‡ji wbwg‡Ë AvwbZ GKwU ¯^Z¡ Avwcj †gvKÏgv|
bIMuv ‡Rjvi AvÎvB mnKvix RR Av`vjZ Gi weÁ mnKvix RR KZ…©K cÖ`Ë g~j 452/1984 bs Ab¨ cÖKvi †gvKÏgvi weMZ 20/03/2011 Bs Zvwi‡Li cÖ`Ë Lvwi‡Ri ivq I wWwµ, hvi wWwµ weMZ 27/03/2011 Bs Zvwi‡L ¯^vÿwiZ; Zvi Am¤§wZ‡Z ms¶zä n‡q ev`xcÿ/ AvcxjKvix wn‡m‡e AÎ Ab¨ cÖKvi 90/2011 bs ¯^Z¡ Avcxj †gvKÏgvwU `v‡qi K‡i‡Qb|
GLb, Avcx‡ji †g‡gv‡Z wK D‡jøL Kiv n‡q‡Q Zvi mswÿß eb©bv D‡jøL Kiv n‡jvt-
Avwc‡j›U/ev`x c‡¶ †g‡gv Ae Avwcj ewY©Z `vex n‡jv- weÁ wePvwiK Av`vjZ ZwK©Z ivq I wWwµ cÖ`v‡b AvBbMZ I Z_¨MZ åg K‡i‡Qb| bvwjkx Rwg‡Z weev`x/‡imcb‡W›U c‡ÿi ‡Kv‡bv ¯^Ë¡, ¯^v_© I `Lj bvB| wePvwiK Av`vjZ wePvh© welq¸‡jv mwVK wb®úwË bv K‡i Kw_Z fzj ivq w`‡q‡Qb| wePvwiK Av`vjZ ev`x c‡ÿi `vexi mg_©‡bi `vwjwjK I †gŠwLK mvÿ¨ ch©v‡jvPbv mwVKfv‡e K‡ib bvB| bvwjkx m¤úwË ev`xc‡ÿi ¯^Z¡, ¯^v_© I `Lj _vKv ¯^‡Z¡I Ges Zr mg_©‡b ev`xc‡ÿi mg_©bgyjK `vwjwiK I †gŠwLK mvÿ¨ _vKv ¯^‡Z¡I D³ wel‡q weÁ wePvwiK Av`vjZ AvBbMZ cÖwZKvi Abyaveb Ki‡Z e¨_© n‡q‡Qb g‡g© D‡jøL K‡i g~j †gvKÏgvq cÖ`Ë Lvwi‡Ri ivq I wWwµ i`-iwn‡Zi cÖv_©bv K‡i‡Qb|
AÎ Avwc‡ji ‡bvwUk cÖvwßi ci gyj 1 bs weev`x/‡imcb‡W›U cÿ Avwcj gvgjvq nvwRi n‡q †Kvb wjwLZ AvcwË bv w`‡jI Avcxj ïbvbx‡Z Ask wb‡q‡Qb|
Avcx‡j wePvh© welqmg~n t
AÎ Avcxj †gvKÏgvq Av‡jvPbv I wm×všÍ MÖn‡Yi myweav‡_© A`¨ wbb¥wjwLZ wePvh© welqmg~n MÖnY Kiv n‡jvt-
1| bIMuv ‡Rjvi AvÎvB mnKvix RR Av`vjZ Gi weÁ mnKvix RR KZ…©K cÖ`Ë g~j 452/1984 bs Ab¨ cÖKvi †gvKÏgvi weMZ 20/03/2011 Bs Zvwi‡Li cÖ`Ë Lvwi‡Ri ivq I wWwµ, hvi wWwµ weMZ 27/03/2011 Bs Zvwi‡L ¯^vÿwiZ; Zv AvBbvbyM I mwVK n‡q‡Q wK bv?
2| ev`x/ Avwc‡j›U †g‡gv Ad Avcxj Abyhvqx cÖvw_©Z cÖwZKvi ‡c‡Z cv‡i wK bv?
Av‡jvPbv I wm×všÍ t
Av‡jvPbv I wm×všÍ MÖn‡Yi myweavi Rb¨ Ges Av‡jvPbvi myweav‡_© Z_v cybive„wË cwinviv‡_© ci¯úi m¤cK©hy³ wm×všÍ Mªn‡bi Rb¨ we‡eP¨ welq `ywU GK‡Î ‡bIqv n‡jvt-
AÎ Ab¨ AvwcjwU ïbvbxKv‡j ev`x/ Avwc‡j›U c‡ÿi I †imcb‡W›U/ weev`x c‡ÿi weÁ †KŠïjx ïbvbx K‡i‡Qb |
ev`x/ Avwc‡j›U c‡ÿi weÁ †KŠïjx Avcxj ïbvbxKv‡j e‡jb- bvwjkx Rwgi gyj gvwjK †ngvw½bx wewbgq `wjj gy‡j wewbgq MÖnxZv‡`i n¯ÍvšÍi K‡i‡Qb Ges ev`x D³ wewbgq `wjj MÖnxZv‡`i †_‡K `wjj gy‡j Lwi` K‡i ¯^Z¡ `L‡j Av‡Qb| †Kej D³ wewbgq `wjj hv ev`xi Kv‡Q bvB Ges Zv mswkøó Awd‡mI bw_ bvB g‡g© wi‡cvU© Av‡Q| ïaygvÎ D³ wewbgq `wjj bv †`Iqvi Kvi‡b ev`xi ¯^Z¡ `Lj bvB D‡jø‡L †gvKÏgv LvwiR K‡i‡Qb| d‡j ev`xiv bvwjkx Rwg ev`x‡`i ¯^Z¡ `L‡j †nZz wePvwiK Av`vj‡Zi ZwK©Z LvwiRv‡`k ivq I wWµx i` iwnZ Pvb I wWµx Pvb|
Ab¨w`‡K 1 bs weev`x/‡imcb‡W›U c‡ÿi weÁ †KŠïjx Avcxj ïbvbxKv‡j e‡jb - bvwjkx Rwg ev`x wewbgq `wjj cÖgvb K‡i bvB| Avcxj Av`vj‡ZI ev`x wewbgq `wjj Zje †`q bvB| ev`x bvwjkx Rwgg Avi Gm †iK‡W©i wfwˇZ AvswkK Rwg wK‡b‡Q g‡g© `vwe K‡i‡Q- †nZz Avi Gm †iKW© eyj Zv ev`xcÿ ïiæ †_‡KB RvbZ Rb¨ AÎ †gvKÏgvi KR Ad GKkb wVK bq Ges Zvgvw`‡Z evwiZ| †ngvw½wbi 4 cyÎ A_P wewbgq `wjj g‡a¨ 5 cyÎ †jLv Rb¨ wewbgq `wjj mwVK bq| Ab¨w`‡K weev`x †ngvw½wbi cyÎ eZx Kb¨v AviwZi Kejv`vi Ges weev`xiv Kejv wb‡q ¯^Z¡ `L‡j Av‡Q|
Kv‡RB ev`xi †gvKÏgv ev`x‡K cÖgvb Ki‡Z n‡e; hv ev`x cÖgvb Ki‡Z cv‡iwb| ev`xi `Lj _vK‡jB n‡ebv; ev`xi ¯^Z¡I _vK‡Z n‡e| ev`x cÿ Zvi ¯^Z¡ `Lj cÖgv‡b mÿg nb bvB| Kv‡RB wePvwiK Av`vjZ mwVK ivq w`‡q‡Qb `vwe K‡i Avcxj bv-gÄyi Pvb|
GLb, Avcx‡ji †g‡gv Gi Av‡jv‡K †`Lv hvq- bIMuv ‡Rjvi AvÎvB mnKvix RR Av`vjZ Gi weÁ mnKvix RR KZ…©K cÖ`Ë g~j 452/1984 bs Ab¨ cÖKvi †gvKÏgvi weMZ 20/03/2011 Bs Zvwi‡Li cÖ`Ë Lvwi‡Ri ivq I wWwµ, hvi wWwµ weMZ 27/03/11 Bs Zvwi‡L ¯^vÿwiZ; Zvi Am¤§wZ‡Z ms¶zä n‡q ev`xcÿ/ AvcxjKvix wn‡m‡e AÎ Ab¨ cÖKvi 90/2011 bs ¯^Z¡ Avcxj †gvKÏgvwU `v‡qi K‡i‡Qb|
D³ †`Iqvbx 452/1984 bs gyj †gvKÏgvi AviwR, Reve, `vwjwjK I †gŠwLK mvÿ¨, ZwK©Z ivq I wWwµ Ges Avwc‡ji †nZymgyn mn bw_ we¯ÍvwiZ fv‡e cvV I ch©v‡jvPbv Kiv n‡jv|
†`Lv hvK- cÿMb Ab¨vb¨ mv‡ÿ¨i gva¨‡g gvgjvwU KZUzKz cÖgvY Ki‡Z ‡c‡i‡Qb Ges †mB †cÖwÿ‡Z weÁ wePvwiK Av`vj‡Zi wm×všÍ mwVK n‡q‡Q wKbvt-
g~j †gvKÏgvi bw_ ch©v‡jvPbvq †`Lv hvq †h,- g~j ev`x/ Avcx‡j›U AviwR‡Z - g~j †gvKÏgvi bvwjkx (K) Zdkxj I (L) Zdwm‡ji 3.41 GKi Rwgi gywj gvwjK †ngvw½bxi 5/3/65 Zvwi‡Li 2316 bs wewbgq `wjj gy‡j Ges Zv †_‡K Avg‡gv³vi Beªvwng †nv‡mb 2687/64-65 bs A‡_bwU‡Kkb †K‡m wbhy³ n‡q Avg‡gv³vi bvwjkx Rwg ivRkvnx †WcywU Kwgkbvi Awd‡mi 150/67 bs AbygwZ †K‡m 6/10/67 Zvwi‡L AbygwZ †c‡q D³ Avg‡gv³vi 12/10/67 Zvwi‡Li `wjj gy‡j wiqvR DwÏb‡K n¯ÍvšÍi Ki‡j D³ wiqvR DwÏb 12/9/78 Zvwi‡L I 23/09/78 Zvwi‡L c„_K 2 LÛ 29836 I 29837 bs `wjj gy‡j bvwjkx bvwjkx (K) Zdkxj I (L) Zdwm‡ji 3.41 GKi Rwg ev`x Lwi` K‡i ¯^Z¡ `L‡j Ges ev`x 1980 mv‡ji 13 wW‡m¤^i gv‡m Lvwi‡Ri Rb¨ Znwkj Awd‡m †M‡j bvwjkx fzwg eve` ågvZ¥K 1 bs weev`xi bvgxq Avi Gm LwZqv‡bi wel‡q Rvb‡Z cv‡i Ges Zv‡Z fwel¨‡Z ¯^Z¡ msµvšÍ RwUjZv Gov‡bvi Rb¨ ev`x‡`i ¯^Z¡ `Ljxq g‡g© `vwe K‡i weev`x‡`i weiæ‡× AÎ ¯^Z¡ †Nvlbvi ‡gvKÏgv K‡iwQ‡jb|
Avevi, g~j ‡gvKÏgvi bw_ †_‡K †`Lv hvq- 2-5 bs weev`x/ ‡imcb‡W›U cÿ wjwLZ Rev‡e AÎvKvi I cÖKv‡i †gvKÏgv APj, cÿ †`v‡l evwiZ, BZ¨vw` `vwe K‡i ev`xi AviwRi mKj weeiY A¯^xKv‡i cÖK…Z weei‡b D‡jøL K‡ib -
AviwR ewY©Z bvwjkx m¤úwË 1 bs weev`x AviwZ ivbxi gvZv †ngvw½bxi| Zvi bv‡g Gm G 675 I 678 bs LwZqvb cÖ¯‘Z nq| †m gi‡b Zvi Iqvwik Kb¨v AviwZ ivbx Ges AviwZ ivbxi bv‡g Avi Gm 52 bs LwZqvb nq| AviwZ †_‡K 2-5 bs weev`xiv bvwjkx AviwZi KvQ †_‡K 3 LÛ `wjj gy‡j bvwjkx (K) Zdwm‡j i 2.95 GKi Ges (L) Zdwm‡ji 0.28 me©‡gvU (K I L) Zdwm‡ji 3.23 GKi 2-5 bs weev`xiv ¯^Z¡ `L‡j| ev`x‡`i wewbgq `wjj Rvj| ZvQvov ev`xcÿ Avi Gm 52 LwZqv‡bi cÖRv AviwZ ivbx PµeZ©x‡K gvwjK ¯^xKv‡i Avi Gm 52 bs LwZqv‡bi 0.44 GKi Rwg Lwi`I K‡i‡Qb 29/9/73 Zvwi‡Li m¤úvw`Z I 23/10/73 Zvwi‡Li †iwR÷ªxK…Z 9345 bs `wjj gy‡j|
Kv‡RB bvwjkx Rwg‡Z ev`x‡`i †Kvb ¯^Z¡ `Lj bvB- †nZz ev`xi wg_¨v †gvKÏgv LiPv mn wWmwg‡mi `vwe Rvbvb|
weÁ wePvwiK Av`vjZ wb‡¤œv³ wePvh©¨ welq wba©vib K‡iwQ‡jbt
1. eZ©gvb AvKvi I cÖKv‡i ev`xi †gvKÏgv Pj‡Z cv‡i wKbv?
2. AÎ †gvKÏgv Zvgvw`‡Z evwiZ wKbv?
3. †gvKÏgvwU cÿ †`v‡l `yó wKbv?
4. . bvwjkx Rwg‡Z ev`x‡`i ¯^Z¡ `Lj Av‡Q wKbv?
5. cÖv_©xZ g‡Z ev`xcÿ cÖwZKvi ‡c‡Z cv‡ib wKbv?
6. ev`xcÿ Avi †Kvb cÖwZKvi †c‡Z cv‡i wKbv?
weÁ wePvwiK Av`vjZ 20/03/2011 Bs Zvwi‡Li cÖ`Ë Lvwi‡Ri ivq I wWwµ, hvi wWwµ weMZ 27/03/11 Bs Zvwi‡L ¯^vÿwiZ; g‡Z D³ †gvKÏgvwU 2-5 bs †gvKv‡ejv weev`xi weiæ‡× †`v-Zidv my‡Î I Acivci weev`x‡`i weiæ‡× GK Zidvmy‡Î webv LiPvq Lvwi‡Ri ZwK©Z ivq I wWµx cÖ`vb K‡i‡Qb|
Zv‡Z iv‡q †`Lv hvq- mKj wePvh© welq g‡a¨ 2-3 bs wePvh© welq GK‡Î wb®úwˇZ ev`x bvwikx Rwgi Avi Gm LwZqvb wel‡q 1973 mvj †_‡KB Rvb‡Zb g‡g© Avi Gm LwZqvb AviwZi bv‡g †R‡b Lwi` K‡i‡Qb g‡g© Revbe›`x I †Rivq ¯^xKvi Kivq Zv †_‡K Zvgvw` AvB‡bi 120 Aby‡”Q‡`i weav‡b 6 eQ‡ii g‡a¨ †gvKÏgv bv Kivq eis 1983 mv‡j AÎ †gvKÏgv Kivq Zvgvw`‡Z evwiZ g‡g© 2 bs wePvh© welq ev`xi weiæ‡× wb®úwË K‡i‡Qb| Ab¨w`‡K cÿ †`vl bvB g‡g© 3 bs wePvh© welq wb®úwË K‡i‡Qb|
Avevi 4 bs wePvh© wel‡q wek` mvÿ¨ Av‡jvPbv K‡i bvwjkx Rwg‡Z ev`xi ¯^Z¡ `Lj cÖgv‡b mÿg nb bvB g‡g© wb®úwË Kivq 5/ 6 bs wePvh© welqI ev`x c‡ÿi cÖwZKz‡j Z_v ¯^Z¡ `Lj cÖgvb Ki‡Z cv‡ib bvB g‡g© wm×všÍ wb‡q iv‡q D³ gyj †gvKÏgv LvwiR K‡i‡Qb|
D³ gyj †gvKÏgvi †`v-Zidv my‡Î LvwiR Gi ivq I wWµx weiæ‡×B ev`xcÿ KZ©„K AÎ ¯^Z¡ Avcxj|
GLb, wePvwiK Av`vj‡Zi ivq I bw_ ch©v‡jvPbvq †`Lv hvq- ev`x c‡ÿ 1 bs ev`x wb‡R wcWweøD-1 mn wcWweøD-4 I wcWweøD-5 `yRb fwjDg mvÿx mn me©‡gvU 5 Rb mvÿx w`‡q‡Qb Ges ev`xc‡ÿ cÖ`k©bx (1 - 4) bs wPwýZ `vwjwjK cÖgvY `vwLj K‡i‡Qb|
Ab¨w`‡K 2-5 bs weev`x c‡ÿ 4 bs weev`x wWWweøD-1 wn‡m‡e mvÿ¨ w`‡q‡Qb Ges cÖ`t K, L, M , N wmwiR I O wPwýZ`vwjwjK cÖgvb `vwLj K‡i‡Qb Ges Zv‡`i c‡ÿ 1 bs weev`x AviwZ ivbx PµeZ©x wWWweøD-3 mn †gvU 3 Rb mvÿx Dc¯’vcb K‡i‡Qb|
‡m‡ÿ‡Î †h‡nZz mKj c‡ÿi `vwjwjK I †gŠwLK mvÿ¨ i‡q‡Q- †nZz D³ mvÿ¨ ¸‡jv AÎ Avcxj Av`vj‡Z wb‡¤œ avivevwnKfv‡e cÿM‡bi `vwe I ci¯úi we‡ivacyb© wel‡q wm×všÍ MÖn‡bi Rb¨ Av‡jvPbv I we‡kølb Kiv n‡jvt-
ev`xi AviwR †_‡K †`Lv hvq- ev`x AviwRi (K) Zdwm‡ji ¸obB †gŠRvi Gm G 675 bs LwZqv‡bi mv‡eK 1024 bs `v‡Mi nvj 1632 bs `v‡Mi 1.76 GKi; mv‡eK 1025 nvj 1633 bs `v‡Mi 1.19 GKi Ges mv‡eK 1023 nvj 1634 Gi evUv 2436 bs `v‡Mi 0.18 GKi †gvU 3.13 GKi Ges AviwRi (L) Zdwm‡ji Gm G 102 bs LwZqv‡bi mv‡eK 933 nvj 1495 bs `v‡Mi 0.20 GKi I mv‡eK 955 nvj 1511 bs `v‡Mi 0.08 GKi †gvU 0.28 GKi me©‡gvU `ywU Zdwm‡j 3.41 GKi fzwg‡Z ¯^Z¡ `Lj g‡g© `vwe K‡i‡Qb|
D‡jøL¨ ev`xi AviwR‡Z nvj Avi Gm LwZqvb bs KZ Zv D‡jøL bvB|
GLb, ev`x I weev`xi cÖ`k©bx (L) Z_v Gm G 897/1 bs LwZqvb †_‡K †`Lv hvq AviwRi (K) Zdwm‡ji mv‡eK 1024 bs `v‡Mi 1.76 GKi; mv‡eK 1025 bs `v‡Mi 1.19 GKi Ges mv‡eK 1023 Gi evUv 2436 bs `v‡Mi 0.10 GKi †gvU 3.05 GKi Ges ev`x I weev`xi cÖ`k©bx (L-1) Z_v Gm G 678 bs LwZqvb †_‡K †`Lv hvq- AviwRi (L) Zdwm‡ji mv‡eK 933 bs `v‡Mi 0.20 GKi I mv‡eK 955 bs `v‡Mi 0.08 GKi †gvU 0.28 GKi Z_v `ywU Zdwm‡ji me©‡gvU 3.33 GKi fzwgi GKK Gm G †iKW©xq gvwjK †ngvw½bx †`e¨v|
bvwjkx Zdwmj fzwgi GKK gvwjK †ngvw½bx Zv Dfq cÿ KZ©…K ¯^xK…ZI I cÖgvwbZ|
GLb, ev`xi `vwe wQj- ‡ngvw½bxi 4 cyÎ I AbšÍ Kzgvi bvwjkx Rwg †c‡q wewbgq `wjj K‡i †`evi Rb¨ Avg‡gv³vi wbhy³ K‡i Beªvwng †nv‡mb‡K Avg‡gv³vi wbhy³ K‡i hvi 5/3/65 Avwi‡Li 2316 bs wewbgq `wjj Kivi ev Zv A‡_bwU‡KU Kivi ev ivRkvnx †WcywU Kwkbvi Awd‡mi 150/67 bs cviwgkb hv 6/10/67 Zvwi‡Li Av‡`k Zvi †Kvb Kwc ev`xcÿ `vwLj I cÖgvb K‡ib bvB|
GLb, ev`xi cÖ`k©bx 3 Z_v AvÎvB Gm Avi Awd‡mi †iwR÷ªxK…Z 11083 bs wewbgq cÎ `wjj Rv‡e`v bKj hv wcWweøD-5 fwjDg mvÿxi mvÿ¨ Øviv cÖ`t 3 wPwýZ n‡q‡Q- †mB Rv‡e`v bKj ch©v‡jvPbvq †`Lv hvq- D³ `wjj g‡a¨ wewbgq †Km AbygwZ †Km bs D‡jøL _vK‡jI `wjj `vZv‡`i gvwjKvbvi eb©bvq 5 Rb `vZvi nK ¯^Z¡ `Ljxq Rwg wn‡m‡e Z_v †ngvw&½wbi 4 cyÎ I 5 bs `vZv wn‡m‡e AbšÍ †gvnb miKv‡ii bvg i‡q‡Q Ges D³ wewbgq `wjj MÖnxZv n‡jb- †gvnv¤§` wiqvR DwÏb Ges `wjj g‡a¨ (K) Zdwm‡ji 1-21 bs µwg‡Ki bvwjkx AviwRi (K I L) Zdwm‡ji me©‡gvU 3.33 GKi fzwg mn Ab¨vb¨ `v‡Mi I LwZqv‡bi me©‡gvU 19.88 GKi fzywg wewbgq Ki‡Qb fviZxq Abvwjkx 14.92 GKi fzwgi mv‡_ Ges wccweøD-5 Gi †Riv †_‡K †`Lv hvq- wZwb †Rivq e‡j‡Qb- D³ Rv‡e`v bK‡ji (K) Zdwm‡ji 9 bs Zdwm‡ji 189 bs `vM Zvi AvbxZ fwjD‡g bvB g‡g© ¯^xKvi K‡i‡Qb|
GLb, ev`x wcWweøD-1 Gi Revbe›`x I †Riv ch©v‡jvPbv Ki‡j †`Lv hvq- †ngvw½bxi 4 cyÎ n‡jI 5 bs `wjj `vZv AbšÍ †gvnb miKvi wKfv‡e Rwgi gvwjK Zv my¯úó bq|
Avi cÖ`t 4 I (M) Z_v Avi Gm 52 bs LwZqvb n‡Z †`Lv hv‡”Q- bvwjkx Zdwm‡ji bvwjkx 3.33 GKi mn Ab¨vb¨ `v‡Mi †gvU 5.14 GKi fzwg eve` AviwZ ivbx PµeZ©x Rs †R¨vwZl P›`ª PµeZ©x bv‡g dvBbvj Avi Gm †iKW© Ges wcWweøD-1 Gi †Riv †_‡K †`Lv hvq- ev`x †Rivq AviZx ivbx PµeZ©x D³ Gm G cÖRv †ngvw½bxi Kb¨v g‡g© ¯^xKvi K‡i‡Qb Ges wZwb †Rivq Av‡iv ¯^xKvi K‡i‡Qb- ev`x D³ AviZx ivbx PµeZ©x‡K †ngvw½bxi Iqvwik †R‡b 1973 mv‡j Rwg wK‡b‡Qb|
GLb, weev`xi cÖ`t wPwýZ `vwjwjK cÖgv‡b †`Lv hv‡”Q †h, ev`x wb‡R 1973 mv‡ji †h `wjj gy‡j AviZx †_‡K bvwjkx Zdwm‡ji `v‡Mi Rwg Lwi` K‡i‡Qb- Zv ¯^xKvi K‡i‡Qb Ges weev`xi Rev‡e ewb©Z 13/10/73 Bs Zvwi‡Li 9345 bs Kejv `wjj gy‡j nvj 52 bs LwZqv‡bi nvj 1495 bs `v‡Mi 18 kZK Rwg I nvj 1512 bs `v‡Mi 26 kZK †gvU 0.44 GKi bvwjkx Rwg ev`x Lwi` K‡i‡Qb Ges D³ `wjjwU weev`x cÖgvb Gi Rb¨ `vwLj bv Ki‡jI ev`x wcWweøD-1 Zvi †Rivq ¯^xKvi K‡i‡Qb g‡g© †`Lv hvq|
d‡j bvwjkx Zdwm‡ji †h Rwg 1967 mv‡ji wewbgq `wjj gy‡j wiqvR DwÏb cv‡”Qb g‡g© `vwe- †mB wewbgq `wjj Gi AšÍf©y³ bvwjkx 3.33 GKi fzwg eve` wewbgq MÖnxZv wiqvR DwÏb bv‡g nvj †iKW© bv nIqv Ges D³ wewbgq `wjj eve` †Kvb bvg LvwiR bv Kiv I LvRbv cÖ`vb bv Kiv Ges wiqvR bv‡g †iKW© bv n‡q ‡ngvw½bxi cyÎ eZx Kb¨vi bv‡g dvBbvj Avi Gm 52 bs LwZqvb nIqv Ges Avi Gm LwZqvb `„y‡ó D³ AviwZ †_‡K bvwjkx (L) Zdwm‡ji mv‡eK 933 nvj 1495 bs `v‡Mi 0.20 GKi Kv‡Z 18 kZK mn Abvwjkx nvj 1512 bs `v‡Mi 26 kZK †gvU 44 kZK Rwg ev`x 1973 mv‡jB AviwZ ivbx PµeZ©x‡K gvwjK ¯^xKv‡i wK‡b †bqvi ¯^xK…wZ Ges D³ AviwZ ivbx PµeZ©x wWWweøD-3 wn‡m‡e weev`xc‡ÿ mvÿ¨ †`Iqvq Ges Zv‡K †Riv K‡i ev`xi wewbgq I Avg‡gv³vi `wjj mg_©‡b †Kvb ¯^xK…wZ Avbq‡b mÿg bv nIqv †_‡K Ges ev`xi 1 I 2 wPwýZ 1978 I 1979 mv‡ji 2 LÛ `wjj hvi `vZv Kw_Z wewbgq MÖnxZv wiqvR DwÏb †_‡K D³ `wjj m¤úwËi AvswkK Z_v gy‡j c~‡e©B bvwjkx (L) Zdwm‡ji mv‡eK 933 nvj 1495 bs `v‡Mi 0.20 GKi Kv‡Z 18 kZK 1973 mv‡jB Lwi` Kivi ¯^xK…wZ mn wcWweøD-5 fwjDg evn‡Ki mvÿ¨ Z_v cÖ`t 3 wPwýZ wewbgq `wjj Gi (K) Zdwm‡ji 9 bs µwg‡Ki 189 bs `v‡Mi †Kvb Rwg gyj evjv‡g bvB g‡g© D‡jøL Kiv mn wewbgq `vZv‡`i Z_v 5 bs wewbgq `vZv wKfv‡e Rwg †cj Zv cÖgvb Ki‡Z bv cviv Ges †ngvw½wbi 4 cyÎ g‡g© AviwZ ivbx PµeZ©x‡K †Rivq †Kvb ¯^xK…wZ Av`v‡q mÿg bv nIqvq Ges weev`xi cÖ`k©bx wPwýZ (N wmwiR) wPwýZ `wjj gy‡j bvwjkx mgy`q fzwg ‡ngvw½bxi Kb¨v Avi Gm cÖRv AviZx ivbx PµeZ©x †_‡K weev`xiv Lwi` Kivi `vwjwjK cÖgvb †_‡K †`Lv hv‡”Q bvwjkx Zdwmj Rwg‡Z ev`x‡`i ¯^Z¡ cÖgv‡b ev`xcÿ mÿg nb bvB e‡jB AÎ Avcxj Av`vjZI g‡b K‡i Ges †m‡ÿ‡Î D³ wel‡q wePvwiK Av`vj‡Zi mv‡_ Avcxj Av`vjZ ¯^Z¡ msµvšÍ wel‡q GKgZ †cvlb Ki‡Q|
GLb, Zvgvw` msµvšÍ wel‡q †h wm×všÍ wePvwiK Av`vjZ Zvi iv‡q e‡j‡Qb- Zv Dc‡ii mvÿ¨ Av‡jvPbvq †`Lv †M‡Q- bvwjkx Rwgi Avi Gm †iKW© AviZx ivbx PµeZ©vi bv‡g Ges wcWweøD-1 ev`x Zvi †Rivq ¯^xKvi K‡i‡Qb- bvwjkx †Rv‡Zi nvj 1495 bs `v‡Mi 0.20 GKi Kv‡Z 18 kZK mn Abvwjkx nvj 1512 bs `v‡Mi 26 kZK †gvU 44 kZK Rwg ev`x 1973 mv‡jB AviwZ ivbx PµeZ©x‡K gvwjK ¯^xKv‡i wK‡b wb‡q‡Qb g‡g© ¯^xKvi K‡i‡Qb|
myZivs D³ wcWweøD-1 Gi †Rivi ¯^xK…wZ †_‡K ¯úó †h, ev`x 1973 mvj †_‡KB AviwZ ivbx bvwjkx Rwgi Avi Gm cÖRv Rvb‡Zb Ges AviZx ivbxi gvwjKvbv I `Lj‡K ¯^xKvi K‡i †bevi c‡i Zvgvw` AvB‡bi 120 Aby‡”Q‡`i weav‡b 1973 mvj †_‡K 6 eQ‡ii g‡a¨ Z_v 1979 mv‡ji g‡a¨ ¯^Z¡ †Nvlbvi †gvKÏgv bv K‡i 1983 mv‡j AÎ gyj †gvKÏgv K‡i‡Qb|
d‡j ev`xi KR Ad GKkb mwVK bq I ev`xi gyj †gvKÏgv Zvgvw`‡ZI evwiZ e‡jB AÎ Avcxj Av`vjZ g‡b Ges D³ wePvh© wel‡q wePvwiK Av`vj‡Zi wm×v‡šÍi mv‡_I AÎ Avcxj Av`vjZ Zvgvw` wel‡qI GKgZ †cvlY Ki‡Q|
GLb, `Lj wel‡q ev`xi †Kvb `vwjwjK cÖgvb bvB Z_v LvwiR LwZqvb, wWwmAvi ev LvRbvi `vwLjv bvB|
Avevi weev`xiI Zv bvB|
GLv‡b- mvÿ¨ AvB‡bi 101 avivi weavb cÖwbavb‡hvM¨ Zv n‡jv -
‡gvKÏgvq hvi †h `vwe A_©vr hvi e‡`Šj‡Z Av`vjZ ‡K ‡h cÿ †Kvb wel‡qi Aw¯ÍZ¡ m¤ú‡K© wek¦vm Kiv‡Z PvB‡e †m `vwe Zv†KB A_©vr †m cÿ‡KB `vwjwjK I †gŠwLK mvÿ¨ Øviv cÖgvY Ki‡Z n‡e|
GLb, †`Lv hvK- AÎ gyj †gvKÏgvq †gŠwLK mvÿxi `Lj msµvšÍ wel‡q mvÿxiv wKiæc mvÿ¨ w`‡q‡Qb t -
ev`xi AviwR †_‡K †`Lv hvq- ev`xiv bvwjkx 3.41 GKi Rwg Lwi` K‡i kvwšÍc~b© †fvM`L‡j g‡g© `vwe K‡i‡Qb Ges mv‡eK 1025 `v‡M cyKz‡i gvQ Pv‡l `Lj Ki‡Qb g‡g© `vwe K‡i‡Qb|
GLb, ev`xc‡ÿ wcWweøD-1 Gi Revbe›`x ch©v‡jvPbvq †`Lv hvq- wZwb Revbe›`x‡Z e‡i‡Qb- bvwjkx Rwg wZwb `Lj K‡ib Ges cyKz‡i gvQ Pvl K‡ib|
Zvi †Riv we‡kølb Ki‡j †`Lv hvq - ev`x c‡ÿi AÎ mvÿx wcWweøD-1 Zvi †Rivq e‡j‡Qb- AviZx i vbxi bv‡g †h Avi Gm LwZqvb Zvi KqwU `vM Zv ej‡Z cv‡ib bv, †K †K `Lj K‡i Zv ej‡Z cv‡ib bv| †gvU m¤úwËi cwigvb ej‡Z cv‡ib bv|
GLb, ev`xc‡ÿ Aci mvÿx wcWweyøD-2 I wcWweøD-3 Gi mvÿ¨ ch©v‡jvPbv Ki‡j †`Lv hvq- Zviv `yR‡bB bvwjkx Rwg ev`xiv `Lj K‡i g‡g© Revbe›`x‡Z ej‡jI Zviv mywbw`©ó KZ cwigvb Rwg Ges Zviv wKfv‡e bvwjkx Rwg wP‡bb Zvi †Kvb mywbw`©ó e³e¨ Zv‡`i mv‡ÿ¨ †`Lv hvq bv|
Ab¨w`‡K 2-5 bs weev`xc‡ÿi Rev‡eI D‡jøL K‡i‡Qb- Zviv bvwjkx `v‡Mi mgy`q 3.33 GKi Rwg Avi Gm cÖRv †_‡K wK‡b ¯^Z¡ `L‡j| Z‡e wKfv‡eK `Lj K‡ib Zv my¯úó K‡ib bvB|
‡m‡ÿ‡Î weev`x‡`i 3 LÛ ¯^Z¡ msµvšÍ `wjj cÖgvb wPwýZ n‡q‡Q|
GLb, wWWweøD-1 Gi Revbe›`x‡Z e‡j‡Qb ZvivI Lwi` K‡i `Lj K‡ib|
Zvi †Rivq †Kvb ˆecwiZ¨ bvB e‡jB †`Lv hvq|
Avevi, weev`xi `LjK mg_©‡b cÖ`Z¡ mvÿx wWWweøD-2 Ges †Lv` Avi Gm cÖRv AviZx ivbx PµeZ©x wwWWweøD-3 wn‡m‡e weev`xi `Lj‡K mg_©b K‡i mvÿ¨ cÖ`vb K‡i‡Qb Ges AviZx‡K †Riv K‡i ev`xcÿ Zvi mvÿ¨‡K wePy¨wZ NUv‡Z mÿg nb bvB e‡jB AÎ Avcxj Av`vjZ g‡b K‡i|
‡m‡ÿ‡Î †h‡nZz ev`x wcWweøD-1 wb‡RB AviZxi Gm Gm cÖRv nIqv ¯^xKv‡i bvwjkx Zdwm‡ji bvwjkx Rwgi g‡a¨ AvswkK Z_v bvwjkx †Rv‡Zi nvj 1495 bs `v‡Mi 0.20 GKi Kv‡Z 18 kZK mn Abvwjkx nvj 1512 bs `v‡Mi 26 kZK †gvU 44 kZK Rwg ev`x 1973 mv‡jB AviwZ ivbx PµeZ©x‡K gvwjK ¯^xKv‡i wK‡b wb‡q‡Qb g‡g© ¯^xKvi K‡i‡Qb Ges †nZz AviZxi gvwjKvbv I `Lj‡K ev`xi A¯^xKv‡ii AvBbZ my‡hvM bvB Ges AviwZ wb‡RB weev`x‡`i Kv‡Q bvwjkx Rwg n¯ÍvšÍ‡i `Lj w`‡q‡Qb g‡g© mvÿ¨ w`‡q‡Qb Ges weev`xi ¯^‡Z¡i `wjj ev`x A‡cÿv AwaK MÖnb‡hvM¨ I mg_©bgyjK nIqvq `Lj mg_©‡b ev`xi wcWweøD-2 I 3 A‡cÿv weev`xi wWWweøD-3 I 2 Gi mvÿ¨‡K AwaK MÖnb‡hvM¨ wbf©i‡hvM¨ I mg_©bgyjK I wek¦vm‡hvM¨ e‡jB AÎ Avcxj Av`vjZI g‡b K‡i|
Kv‡RB bvwjkx Zdwm‡ji 3.33 GKi fzwg‡Z ev`xcÿ Gi ¯^Z¡ `LjKvi g‡g© †h, `vwe Zv MÖnb‡hvM¨, wbf©i‡hvM¨, †hŠw³K I wek¦vm‡hvM¨ `vwjwjK I †gŠwLK mvÿ¨ Øviv ev`xcÿ cÖgv‡Y mÿg nb bvB e‡jB AÎ Avcxj Av`vj‡Z cÖgvb n‡q‡Q - †m‡nZz ev`x/Avcx‡j›U c‡ÿi weÁ †KŠïjxi Avcxj ïbvbxKv‡ji hyw³Z‡K©i `vwe A‡cÿv ‡imcb‡W›U/weev`xc‡ÿi c‡ÿi weÁ †KŠïjxi hyw³Z‡K©i `vweB AwaK MÖnb‡hvM¨, ‡hŠw³K I AvBbm½Z e‡jB AÎ Avcxj Av`vjZ g‡b K‡i|
myZivs Dc‡ii mgy`q `vwjwjK I †gŠwLK mv‡ÿ¨i Av‡jv‡K wePvwiK Av`vj‡Zi ‡h ZwK©Z ‡`v-Zidv ivq I wWµx cÖ`vb Kiv n‡q‡Q- Zv‡Z Z_¨MZ ev AvBbMZ ‡Kvb e¨vZ¨q N‡U bvB e‡jB AÎ Avcxj Av`vjZ g‡b K‡i Ges wePvwiK Av`vjZ mvÿx‡`i mvÿ¨ mwVK I AvBbm½Ziæ‡c wePvi we‡kølb K‡i bvB g‡g© Avcx‡j›U/ev`xi `vwe mwVK I AvBbvbyM bq e‡jB AÎ Avcxj Av`vjZ g‡b K‡i|
m½Z Dc‡ii mgy`q Kvi‡bB wePvwiK Av`vj‡Zi ‡`v-Zidv ivq I wWµx AvBbvbyM nIqvq Zv‡Z n¯Í‡ÿc Kiv †hŠw³K, MÖnb‡hvM¨ I AvBbm½Z bq e‡jB AÎ Avcxj Av`vjZ g‡b K‡i|
d‡j Dc‡ii mgy`q mvÿ¨ Av‡jvPbv, we‡kølb I Kvibvax‡b Avcx‡ji wePvq© welq 2 wU AvcxjKvix/ ev`xc‡ÿi cÖwZKz‡j wb®úwË Kivi wm×všÍ MÖnb µ‡g bIMuv ‡Rjvi AvÎvB mnKvix RR Av`vjZ Gi weÁ mnKvix RR KZ…©K cÖ`Ë g~j 452/1984 bs Ab¨ cÖKvi †gvKÏgvi weMZ 20/03/2011 Bs Zvwi‡Li cÖ`Ë Lvwi‡Ri ivq I wWwµ, hvi wWwµ weMZ 27/03/11 Bs Zvwi‡L ¯^vÿwiZ; Zvnv envj I ejer ivLvi wm×všÍ M„nxZ n‡jv|
cÖ`Ë †KvU© wd mwVK|
AZGe,
Av‡`k nq †h,
AÎ Avwcj †gvKÏgvwU ¸bv¸b wePv‡i †`v-Zidvm~‡Î Avwc‡j›U/ ev`xc‡ÿi cÖwZK‚‡j Ges †imcb‡W›U /weev`xc‡ÿi AbyKz‡j webv LiPvq bv-gÄyi (wWmGjvDW) Kiv n‡jv Ges weÁ wePvwiK Av`vjZ KZ…©K cÖ`Z¡ Z_v bIMuv ‡Rjvi AvÎvB mnKvix RR Av`vjZ Gi weÁ mnKvix RR KZ…©K cÖ`Ë g~j 452/1984 bs Ab¨ cÖKvi †gvKÏgvi weMZ 20/03/2011 Bs Zvwi‡Li cÖ`Ë Lvwi‡Ri ivq I wWwµ, hvi wWwµ weMZ 27/03/11 Bs Zvwi‡L ¯^vÿwiZ; Zvnv envj I ejer ivLvi wm×všÍ M„nxZ n‡jv|
Awej‡¤^ AÎ iv‡qi Abywjwcmn Gj.wm.Avi mswkøó weÁ wePvwiK Av`vj‡Zi wbKU †cªiY Kiv ‡nvK|
Avgvi Kw_Z g‡Z Kw¤úDUv‡i K‡¤úvRK…Z
I Avgv KZ©„K ms‡kvwaZ|
(‡gvt ZvRyj Bmjvg wgTv) (‡gvt ZvRyj Bmjvg wgTv)
hyM¥ †Rjv RR hyM¥ †Rjv RR
hyM¥ †Rjv RR-cÖ_g Av`vjZ hyM¥ †Rjv RR-cÖ_g Av`vjZ
bIMuv| bIMuv|
দায়বর্জন বিবৃতি (DISCLAIMER)
এই ওয়েবসাইটে প্রকাশিত অধস্তন আদালতের রায় বা আদেশের অনুলিপি কেবল মামলার সকল পক্ষ, বিজ্ঞ আইনজীবী এবং জনসাধারণের বিচার-প্রক্রিয়ায় সহজ অভিগম্যতা নিশ্চিতকরণের অভিপ্রায়ে অনলাইনে প্রকাশ করা হয়েছে; রায় বা আদেশের অনুলিপি সইমোহরী/জাবেদা নকলের (certified copy) বিকল্প হিসেবে ব্যবহার করা যাবে না। অধস্তন আদালতের রায় ও আদেশ বাস্তবায়নের ক্ষেত্রে মামলার নথিতে বিধৃত মূল অংশ (রায় বা আদেশ) প্রণিধানযোগ্য।